Why Are Drum Traps illegal? Check The Facts!

why are drum traps illegal? The reason why a drum trap is deemed illegal lies in its lack of self-cleaning properties and the difficulty it poses when it comes to maintenance. Additionally, it fails to meet the requirement of having a smooth flowing interior surface, which further contributes to its prohibition. So, let’s dive into the world of drum traps and uncover the truth together.

Understanding Drum Traps

To start our journey, we need to grasp the concept of drum traps and their purpose in plumbing systems. Drum traps are plumbing fixtures designed to prevent the escape of sewer gases while allowing wastewater to flow freely. They consist of a drum-shaped container with an inlet and an outlet, creating a water seal that blocks the gases from entering the living spaces.

Unlike other plumbing traps, such as P-traps or S-traps, drum traps feature a rotating cover that can be unscrewed for maintenance or to clear blockages. Historically, drum traps were commonly used in older plumbing systems and were regarded as a reliable solution for trapping debris and preventing sewer odors from infiltrating homes.

The Problems with Drum Traps

While drum traps served their purpose in the past, they come with a set of inherent problems that eventually led to their prohibition. Let’s take a closer look at these issues and understand why drum traps are no longer deemed suitable for modern plumbing systems.

Inadequate Water Flow and Drainage

One significant drawback of drum traps is their propensity to impede water flow. The design of the drum-shaped container creates resistance, restricting the volume and velocity of water passing through the trap. This reduced flow can lead to several consequences, including slow drainage, backups, and even pipe corrosion.

Imagine standing in the shower, waiting impatiently for the water to drain while it stubbornly lingers around your ankles. Frustrating, isn’t it? Well, that’s precisely the kind of inconvenience caused by drum traps. Their inefficient flow hampers the functionality of plumbing systems, affecting our daily routines and potentially causing damage over time.

Accumulation of Debris and Blockages

Another pressing issue with drum traps is their tendency to accumulate debris and sediment. The rotating cover, while intended to provide access for cleaning, can also inadvertently trap hair, soap scum, grease, and other solid substances. Over time, this accumulation can cause clogs and blockages, leading to backups and unsanitary conditions within our plumbing systems.

Picture the nightmare scenario: a clogged drum trap causing wastewater to overflow into your bathroom, creating a mess that requires extensive cleaning and costly repairs. Trust me, it’s an experience you’d rather avoid. Drum traps’ design flaws make them more susceptible to blockages, making them an impractical choice in modern plumbing.

Difficulties with Maintenance and Repair

Maintaining and repairing drum traps is no walk in the park. Due to their construction and placement, accessing and cleaning these traps can be a challenging and time-consuming task. In some cases, dismantling parts of the plumbing system may be necessary, increasing costs and causing significant inconveniences for homeowners.

If you’re envisioning yourself hunched over, contorting your body into unnatural positions just to clean a drum trap, think again. These traps often require professional intervention, adding yet another layer of complexity and expense to the equation. It’s clear that the hassle associated with maintaining and repairing drum traps outweighs any perceived benefits they might have had.

Legal and Code Regulations

Now that we understand the limitations of drum traps, it’s crucial to explore the legal aspect of their use. Plumbing codes and standards exist to ensure the safety, efficiency, and functionality of plumbing systems in residential and commercial buildings. These codes are continuously updated to keep pace with technological advancements and lessons learned from past practices.

In recognition of the issues discussed earlier, drum traps have been included in plumbing codes and subsequently prohibited. The decision to ban drum traps was not arbitrary but rather a result of careful consideration of the risks and drawbacks associated with their usage. Protecting public health and promoting efficient plumbing systems were the driving forces behind these regulations.

Alternatives to Drum Traps

Fortunately, the world of plumbing has not left us empty-handed after saying goodbye to drum traps. Various alternatives have emerged that offer superior performance, ease of maintenance, and compliance with plumbing codes. Let’s explore some of these modern plumbing traps that have effectively replaced the outdated drum traps.

Contemporary plumbing systems often employ P-traps, S-traps, and bottle traps, depending on the specific requirements of the installation. P-traps, shaped like the letter “P,” are the most commonly used traps. Their simple design incorporates a U-shaped bend that effectively traps water to create a seal, preventing sewer gases from entering living spaces.

S-traps, as the name suggests, resemble the letter “S” and were historically used as an alternative to drum traps. While they offer a similar functionality to P-traps, their use is now limited due to potential siphoning issues. Lastly, bottle traps feature a compact design and are often used in areas where space is limited, such as under sinks or basins. These traps provide an elegant solution while remaining easy to clean and maintain.


What is the problem with drum traps?

Drum traps come with several inherent problems that led to their prohibition. One major issue is their tendency to impede water flow and drainage. The design of drum traps restricts the volume and velocity of water passing through, leading to slow drainage, backups, and potential pipe corrosion. Another problem is the accumulation of debris and sediment within drum traps, which can cause blockages and backups, resulting in unsanitary conditions. Additionally, the complexities involved in accessing and cleaning drum traps make maintenance and repairs difficult and costly.

When did they stop using drum traps?

The usage of drum traps has significantly declined over time, and their discontinuation can be traced back to the advancement of plumbing codes and regulations. As plumbing standards evolved, the limitations and problems associated with drum traps became more apparent, leading to their eventual prohibition. While the exact timeline may vary in different regions, drum traps began to phase out as more efficient and reliable alternatives emerged, offering improved performance and easier maintenance.

Are drum traps still used?

In general, the use of drum traps in modern plumbing systems has greatly diminished. Their inherent problems, as discussed earlier, have prompted the plumbing industry to move away from their usage. Most plumbing codes and regulations now prohibit the installation of drum traps in new constructions or renovations. However, it’s important to note that specific regulations may vary by jurisdiction, so it’s advisable to consult local plumbing codes and professionals for accurate information regarding their use in a particular area.

Why did they use drum traps?

Drum traps were commonly used in the past due to their intended function of preventing the escape of sewer gases while allowing wastewater to flow freely. They provided a way to create a water seal, blocking the entry of unpleasant odors into living spaces. Additionally, drum traps were regarded as a solution for trapping debris and sediment, aiming to keep plumbing systems clean and odor-free. However, the limitations and drawbacks of drum traps, such as reduced water flow, accumulation of debris, and difficulties with maintenance, eventually led to their disuse and prohibition.

What can I replace a drum trap with?

If you’re looking to replace a drum trap in your plumbing system, there are several alternatives available. Common options include P-traps, S-traps, and bottle traps. P-traps, shaped like the letter “P,” are the most widely used traps in modern plumbing. S-traps, resembling the letter “S,” were historically used as an alternative to drum traps, but their use is now limited due to siphoning issues. Bottle traps, on the other hand, offer a compact design suitable for spaces with limited room, such as under sinks or basins. These modern traps are designed to provide efficient water flow, easy maintenance, and compliance with plumbing codes and regulations.


In our quest for balance and efficiency, it’s crucial to understand the reasons behind certain regulations, such as the banning of drum traps in plumbing systems. We’ve explored the limitations of drum traps, including their impact on water flow, accumulation of debris, and difficulties with maintenance. Plumbing codes and standards have rightly evolved to prioritize safety and functionality, leading to the development of alternative traps that offer improved performance and ease of use.

When it comes to modifying or upgrading your plumbing system, always consult with professionals who can provide expert advice tailored to your specific needs. Together, we can create harmonious plumbing systems that seamlessly support our daily lives while keeping us safe and comfortable. So, bid farewell to the drum traps of the past and embrace the innovative solutions that pave the way for a better, more balanced plumbing future.

Leave a Comment